IAS 37 and IAS 38 Exam Mistakes: ICAG FR Guide

Financial report with cost and expense calculations, illustrating IAS 37 and IAS 38 financial reporting

Introduction

The November 2024 sitting was the first Financial Reporting paper under ICAG’s 2024–2029 syllabus, and about 39% of candidates passed. Almost everyone did well on ratios. The trouble was Question Two: four short scenarios on IAS 37, IAS 10, IAS 38 and IFRS 12. The Chief Examiner’s comment was brief: “Many candidates could not provide the right responses.”

This article shows how to answer each scenario using one method: Trigger, Test, Treatment.

What the Report Actually Said

On the paper overall: “A greater number of the candidates demonstrated lack of understanding of how to apply the respective IFRS in the preparation of financial statements.” On the weight of the standards: “the content and application of the IFRSs constitute about 70% of the syllabus and that hardly can a candidate pass the Financial Reporting paper if he/she does not put premium on the learning of the IFRSs.”

Part (a): IAS 37 Provisions (6 marks)

Warranty, large population: expected value.

Working GH¢
3,200 × 10% × 70% × GH¢64 14,336
3,200 × 10% × 30% × GH¢200 19,200
Provision 33,536

Dr Profit or loss GH¢33,536; Cr Provision for repair costs GH¢33,536.

Lawsuit, single obligation. The question states the lawyer’s view that it is “more likely that the company will not be found liable”. On that wording, no present obligation is probable: no provision, and a contingent liability is disclosed unless the outflow is remote. The published scheme instead treats liability as probable and provides GH¢24,000, the most likely outcome. In the exam, state the test, conclude on the wording, and add the alternative in one line.

Part (b): IAS 10 (4 marks)

The court ruled on 8 January 2024 on a case heard in October 2023. The ruling gives evidence of conditions at the 31 December 2023 reporting date, so it is an adjusting event (IAS 10 para 9(a)). Reverse the GH¢60,000 provision; the scheme nets the GH¢20,000 legal costs awarded against the legal costs borne.

Part (c): IAS 38 Carrying Amount (7 marks)

Item Treatment GH¢000
Operating licence (10 years) 200 − 200/10 180
Website (planning stage) Expensed, SIC-32 0
Personal computers Tangible, IAS 16 0
Windows operating system Integral to hardware, IAS 16 0
Microsoft Office 24 − (24/3 × 6/12) 20
Induction training Expensed, IAS 38 para 69 0
Novel rights (indefinite life) Held at cost; no active market to revalue 90
Carrying amount 290

Part (d): IFRS 12 (3 marks)

Wesseh LTD is governed by an operating agreement, so voting rights are not the dominant factor in deciding control. It meets the definition of a structured entity.

📌 EXAM TIP: Every mini-IFRS scenario has a trigger phrase: “large population”, “more likely”, “after the reporting period”, “no active market”. Underline it, apply the standard’s test, and end with a treatment and a number. Definitions alone score little.

Conclusion

Question Two did not test whether candidates had read the standards. It tested whether they could use them. Trigger, Test, Treatment turns each scenario into a short decision with a figure attached, which is what the marking scheme rewards.

Ready to Go Deeper?

My full exam preparation course covers this and every other topic you need. Get started here on Profs Study Hub.

Join the Profs Accountancy Solutions newsletter for free weekly study tips and exam breakdowns, and get the Profs textbook in hardcopy (available at the institutes and agents nationwide) or digital format.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *